It is always interesting and enlightening when your opponent tips his hand or reveals his next play. Even if it shows something you had already guessed, there is a satisfaction that comes from knowing that your guess is right.
For instance, when Planned Parenthood is caught repeatedly lying to and deceiving women, they have tipped their hand. It becomes clear that what we guessed—that they do not care about the wellbeing of women and are only in it for the money—is true. Similarly, yesterday's decision in Perry v. Schwarzenegger, and the arguments surrounding it, tip the hand and show their motivations.
In this case, what tips the hand is not just what is said, but also what is not said: I still have not heard from any gay "marriage" advocate why a government ought to grant special recognition to gay relationships. Instead, the argument seems to be, "well, heterosexuals get marriage licenses, so we should to." This is an argument with the maturity of a two year old.
Lest we forget, remember that gays are not banned from getting married. Any two men could go to Vegas and profess their undying love for eternity—or at least the next seven to 15 years—in front of their friends, family, or loved ones. This isn't merely about marriage as a social institution. This is about marriage as a government-sanctioned relationship. And that's the case that I've never heard made.
To me, gay "marriage" seems kind of like a male tampon. What's the point? If the point of marriage is to encourage through law the just and proper use of the sexual facilities so that children grow up with their parents and women are not abandoned by deadbeat dads, why do those whose sexual acts cannot result in children need these same legal encouragements? But I suppose our society has drifted away from that notion of marriage. Marriage is just something you do to make you feel good. And feeling good is so important that now, apparently, we have a fundamental unenumerated right to a marriage license.
The usual arguments for why government ought to recognize gay "marriage" tend to invoke things such as hospital visitation rights or power of attorney. These arguments fall flat once you realize that all 50 states already grant hospital visitation rights with a simple legal document. And power of attorney can be granted to anyone, not just a spouse, again with a legal document. In fact, the state of California already grants gay couples all the same benefits as married heterosexual couples. They already have everything except the title.
Which is what tips the hand. Gay "marriage" isn't about equality, it's about approval.
Despite common social prejudices, homosexuals are in every way legally equal to heterosexuals, and enjoy all the same rights and benefits. They can't be fired for being gay, they are not taxed more, they don't have separate drinking fountains, or have to give up their seats when a straight person gets on the bus. They even have all the same rights and restrictions regarding marriage as does a heterosexual: a straight man cannot marry another man either. Despite claims that they're "second-class citizens", they clearly are not, at least from a legal perspective, and to call them such is an insult to those who really were second-class. Some may say, "but what about the military!" Even they don't ban homosexuals. Only homosexual acts, which is a different thing entirely, unless you maintain that a person and his actions are equivalent.
No, the real second-class citizens are those in the womb. They are the ones to whom basic human rights are denied. I wonder how the gay-rights lobby would react if it could be demonstrated that an unborn baby was gay. Would he suddenly start having rights? Perhaps we should jump on the phony "gay gene" bandwagon.
But the gay "marriage" advocates aren't interested in mere equality of persons; they want gay relationships to be considered equivalent, and that's the approval they got in this decision. "Rather than being different, same-sex and opposite-sex unions are, for all purposes relevant to California law, exactly the same," says Judge Walker, an H.W. Bush appointee, reassuring us that Souter was not the only judicial activist Bush appointed.
Of course, from my side of the sexual revolution, and as a father, I wonder if Judge Walker has ever held a baby, or understands the difference between sexual unions that might produce offspring and those that can't. But then again, things that are obvious from my perspective on this side of the revolution, seem to baffle those on the other side. I mean, don't we already have ways of preventing sexually transmitted disease and unwanted pregnancy? It's called "consider the consequences of your actions." What's the fuss about?
And in the end, that's what this all boils down to: furthering the agenda of the sexual revolution. The sexual revolution was one aspect brought about by a changing social philosophy; that of self-gratification as the highest good. Of course, self-gratification comes with a price. There are consequences to deal with.
Take food for example. "Hungry? Why wait?" The Snicker's slogan perfectly summarizes this philosophy. I want what I want now. But wait! There are consequences to our actions! If we eat whatever we want whenever we want, we'll get fat. It should come as absolutely no surprise that the nation's biggest health risk is obesity and the most frequently performed medical procedure is abortion. Those are related. Of course, we want to forestall those consequences, but we don't want to work at it. The gym is hard work, as is chastity. We prefer our consequence alleviations in pill form. Introducing birth control pills and diet pills. Those, too, are related.
The easiest way to deal with consequences is pretend they aren't consequences. They just happen to unlucky people. Pregnancy becomes and accident. Poor young girls who didn't do anything wrong are, in our president's words, punished with a baby. But if babies aren't a consequence of sex, then there really is no difference between heterosex and homosex. But then if there's no difference, the only possible reason for opposing it is bigotry. So it's easy to understand why that term is bandied about so often in the debate. (I propose a corollary to Godwin's Law: as the length of conversation with a liberal increases, the probability of being called a racist, sexist, homophobe, or bigot approaches 1.)
But simply denying the consequences for yourself is not enough. We require approval for our actions. What a sinner likes the least is to be called out for his sin. It is little wonder that the heterosexual revolutionaries are on the homosexual bandwagon. Legal approval for gay "marriage" gives further approval for fornication.
For this reason, I often feel sorry for the homosexuals who have been caught in the fight for chastity, used as both a human shield and a weapon by the revolutionaries. The real fight is not about whether homosexuals should be granted the rights of heterosexuals. It's over the fundamental nature of sex, and the proper attitude towards it.
A society that embraces gay "marriage" is one that is doomed to suffer unwanted pregnancy, sexually transmitted disease, divorce, broken families, and abortion. Of course, homosexuality can only propagate one of these things, so one may ask how the others are related. Gay "marriage" is not the cause but rather the symptom. While the pro-matrimony camp likes to make the argument that homosexual unions will weaken marriage, I suspect that the damage has already been done. The fact that we are at the point where we are having fierce debates over the legalization of gay "marriage" indicates that already the notions of chastity have fallen by the wayside. Governmentally-sanctioned homosexual unions can't make things that much worse, but they certainly can keep them from getting better.
I simply cannot imagine a society that encourages homosexuals to fornicate freely, and even grants approvals and blessings to them for doing so, and at the same time demands that heterosexuals take complete responsibility for their actions and treat sex as the awesome and terrifying power that it is. No, sex is either completely free for all, or is completely sacred to all. And if its as cheap as a Snicker's, people, particularly women, will get fat.
This is, of course, related to the abstinence education debate. Abstinence education is only as effective as society permits it. If children have 30 minutes in school being taught that refraining from sex is the only sure way to avoid pregnancy and STIs, and the rest of their waking lives is spent in a culture that drenches them with sex, sexual imagery, and the idea—furthered by permitting gay "marriage"—that sex need not have consequences, what message are they going to learn? Of course they will have sex. But then we have those nasty consequences to deal with! Unwanted pregnancy and STIs abound! The "solution", then, is to hand out condoms like they're candy. But of course, this only furthers the idea that sex is free. More sex and, when the condoms inevitably fail, more pregnancy and disease.
From my side of the revolution the solution is clear: chastity. But then I am called a bigot who promotes inequality for daring to suggest such a thing.
So the choice is between chastity and fornication, homosexual unions and matrimony, happiness or sorrow. Gay "marriage" represent such a tiny part of it. The damage, if any, done by one gay couple fornicating is negligible. The damage done to the society that encourages it is immense.
Well put and well written!
ReplyDeleteI have to be honest, I worry about the future our children will have to face. I think that's the one thing I stress about the most, especially when things like yesterday happen.
I can only hope and pray God grants me the strength, knowledge, and determination (well, I don't have any trouble with determination =p ) to make sure my kids grow up with the correct mind set and moralities I did.
~ The Resident Murloc
Prepare your children to be martyrs. Seriously.
ReplyDeleteCPC Statement 11 - Many women who have had an abortion now have bad flashbacks whenever they hear a vacuum.
ReplyDeleteFact - Assumes that everyone reacts the way one person does. Not everyone reacts the same.
CPC Statement 12 - Everyone who has an abortion regrets it even if she says she doesn't.
Fact - Assumes that everyone reacts the way one person does. Not everyone reacts the same.
CPC Statement 13 - The only birth control you need is abstinence.
Fact - While this is true, it also indicates that there are no other options.
The city of Baltimore (and potentially Austin) has a law that requires CPCs to post what they do not offer. Just as pools are required to post that there is no lifeguard on duty, so to should the CPCs state that there is no medical person on staff, causing them to post that they are centers that provide pregnancy tests and pregnancy counseling, but do not offer any medical services. And while they do offer pregnancy tests and ultrasounds, the people who work there have no medical training, so they have no idea how to read an ultrasound, especially if there is a problem or abnormality.
However, the issue in this post was not really abortion, even though everything above makes it seem that way. The issue highlighted here is gay marriage.
Same-sex marriage is not asking for special recognition to gay relationships. It is simply asking for them to be seen as equal. At this junction, we have a separate but equal idea of marriage in this country. This has been the case throughout history whenever social issues have come to the forefront. When interracial marriage was introduced, it was seen as the bane of people's existence.
Homosexuals do have the rights of everyone else except in this one. And I suppose we can take the route that marriage is not a right but a privilege, but then we get into hegemony and privilege and that becomes a controversial topic and this one is controversial enough, so let's not go there.
(cont.)
So I suppose the main question is why does anyone get married in the first place? Some would say love, other say for security (marriage protects the woman, the man and the children) and other say that the purpose of a marriage is to raise a family. So simply because gay people cannot have children naturally they should be unable to wed? What does that say about people who happen to be infertile? Shouldn't they follow the same rules? What about people who abuse their children/each other? If the purpose is for security and there is no security, should the marriage be invalidated? What about if love goes out of the equation?
ReplyDeleteIt seems to me that there exists the idea that we should be picky about what we will allow to happen and what we won't. Society and religions allow for divorce/annulment on certain grounds (and I really hate that no-fault divorce is acceptable) such as an unconsummated marriage, abuse (be it sexual, emotional or physical), etc.
If the unmarried Judge Walker has ever held a baby, perhaps it was someone’s adopted baby because they themselves were not able to conceive naturally.
I don't disagree that we live in a society of instant gratification and entitlement. And perhaps there are far too many easy ways out, but what does this have to do with marriage. Because one person might consider being homosexual to be a sin does not mean that that person does. You are more than willing to call me all sorts of horrible names (although I know that you never would - that's the thing I honest and truly love about Jesus), but it doesn't mean that I would call myself them nor accept your titles.
The attitudes of sex in this country are off, yes it's true. The attitude of sex should be: Here is the situation. Here are the possible consequences. Here's why you should not do it before you are ready/married (however you choose to put it). Here's the best way to not have to deal with them - Have respect for your body. Have love for yourself. Have trust and faith in your decisions and your intuitions. Have enough self-respect and self-confidence to ignore what the media/peers tell you. Surround yourself with like-minded people or have enough chutzpah to tell those you choose to surround yourself with to piss off. However, just because that is how we should raise our children does not mean that our ideal has the potential to come true.
I cannot see how same-sex marriage would weaken marriage. I have never been able to see how love can weaken marriage. The institution of marriage has been challenged by lack of respect for our spouses, lack of love for our spouses, lack of conviction, enthusiasm in temptation and lack of condemnation from friends.
I can see what you mean about the separation between homosexuals and heterosexuals in the realm of responsibility for their actions regarding the possible consequences of sex. However, you cannot negate the fact that things just don't work any other way. I like the analogy, but it doesn't work the biology department.
I agree that the choice is between all those things, but I cannot understand how homosexual unions equal sorrow. I plan on teaching my children that some people have Christmas trees and Santa while we have menorahs and latkas just as you plan on teaching your children that some people get drunk and try to forget the name of a bad guy in a story (Purim) whereas you guys give things up (Lent). Encouraging a difference in religion makes our society rich and diverse. Why does allowing same-sex marriage do the opposite?
Homosexuals already have the same right to marry as heterosexuals. They always have. A homosexual man is just as free to marry any woman who will have him as a heterosexual man. If marrying a woman does not appeal to him, that is his choice. If he wants to have an intimate relationship with another man, he is also free to do that. If he and his partner want to enjoy the same legal privileges as married couples, such as hospital visitation, inheritance, joint bank accounts, etc., that is also already available in many if not all states. The same applies to homosexual women. In fact, in California domestic partnerships enjoy all the same privileges as married heterosexual couples already. The only difference is that the homosexual relationship is not called "marriage". The people of California want to reserve that term for the exclusive, committed relationship between one man and one woman. That is all. The question is, why are gays who condemn the citizens of California who voted for Prop. 8 so fixated on the term "marriage"?
ReplyDeleteMom/Grandma B
ReplyDeleteI don't deny that is a decent question. Why are people so focused on the term marriage? I suppose it's like telling a child not to touch the stove or telling you not to think about an elephant. When someone tells you that you can't do something in this day and age, they tend to try to do everything in their power to change that. Is that right? Not necessarily, but it is the mark of our times (and we're back to discussing instant gratification and entitlement).
We (my spouse and I) would gladly give up our marriage license for a domestic partnership if the government would get out of the marriage business. "Marriage" should be a religious entity not something that the government allows people to get.
And to ask, why are heterosexuals so fixated on the term "marriage" as well?
Marriage is not a religious institution. If it were, it would be specific to certain religions and others would not have it. Also, atheists would not get marred if it were merely religious.
ReplyDeleteMarriage is a societal institution designed primarily to ensure that children are raised by their parents. It also serves the secondary functions of protecting women (and to a lesser extent, men) from abandonment.
Government has every right and duty to be involved in enforcing this social institution. It is in a society's best interest that children be raised by their parents.
Government involvement in marriage should have two purposes. Firstly, it should positively encourage spouses to stay together and grant them benefits to ease the burdens of child-rearing. Secondly, it should negatively discourage couples from separating, to the detriment of their children.
Longer response to follow.
One of the reasons we named our most recent son Daniel James is because we thought having two patrons (Daniel -- thrown to the lions, St. James -- first apostle martyr) who refused to compromise their commitment to the truth in the face of political persecution were good patrons to have in these times.
ReplyDeleteExcellent post, Joe.